Two recent stories in the news led me to thinking about our society today and the ethical world we live in.
Here in Oregon, Governor John Kitzhaber and his fiance’ Cylvia Hayes are facing multiple investigations by the Attorney General and The Oregon Ethics Commission for influence peddling, corruption and misuse of state resources. The Governor has of course denied any wrongdoing but in the last week or two, the denials have become more obfuscated and remind many people of former President Bill Clinton’s famous “”It depends on what the meaning of the word ‘is’ is,” answer to an investigation into his sexual encounter with Monica Lewinsky.
Claiming he knows nothing about his fiance’s tax returns and backtracking on his definition of the “First Lady” as a public official, the whole thing unfortunately looks like an older man, taken in by a younger woman who had very ambitious plans for herself and used him to try and make those plans happen. But the problem is that he is Oregon’s Governor and while many would feel sympathy for anyone who was taken advantage of, emotionally and financially, more and more it appears she not only took advantage of him but of all Oregonians in an attempt at personal gain and glory.
Ethically, they both had to know what they were doing was wrong or at the very least, in a very gray area. Especially for Kitzhaber, who has been involved in politics for almost 40 years, he must have realized at some point that what was going on was just plain wrong. If that is not the case, he had to be so befuddled and confused by his fiance’s charms as to raise other questions about his competency and ability to carry out the duties of the office of Governor.
This kind of naked ambition and the arrogance often accompanying it was also highlighted in another story recently release about the U.S. Little League World Series Champions from Chicago, IL. After multiple investigations, it was found that the adults involved in drawing up the league boundary and registering players had falsified maps and otherwise rigged the system in order to recruit a “Super All Star” team to compete in the Little League World Series (LLWS). The team ultimately won the US Little League World Series but have now had their title vacated because the truth has come out.
Once again, we see a situation where ethics were compromised or disregarded all in order for someone, or in this case an entire team and their families, to have a chance at fame and glory. Some of those players may have stood to benefit financially from winning the LLWS either through endorsements, the possibility of scholarships or future baseball-related employment. How many of the parents of those kids wouldn’t talk to college recruiters about their son or daughter winning the U.S. World Series and then competing internationally? How many of them would try to turn a child’s game into a paycheck? Now, how many of them, and their children, are forever tainted as a member of the group of All Stars who were involved in rigging a Little League World Series?
As a President of a local Little League, this story is particularly difficult for me to hear about because every year, I have to turn away potential players who would like to play for us but can’t, precisely because of boundary issues. It’s a difficult thing to do because I want those players to have a good experience and in many cases, the reasons are very innocent: They want to play with their friends, the parents work closer to our fields than their “home” fields and it would be easier on them, etc. But I can’t take them and I won’t take them.
I won’t jeopardize our entire League’s future and reputation because someone wants to play with a friend. As much as it pains me, I can’t put every other player at risk for the benefit of one or two players. I wish we didn’t live in a world where that’s the way things have to be, but it is because of people like the parents of the Jackie Robinson West All Stars from Chicago, IL that we all must follow the rules and do what is right.
In both cases, ethics and any kind of a moral compass seem to have been discarded in favor of a “win at any cost” mentality where the prize and the glory were definitely more important than doing the right thing. And in both cases, the negative effects of their actions have impacted many more people than just those individuals.
For the Jackie Robinson West All Star team, the punishment has been handed out now that the truth is known.
I only hope that Governor Kitzhaber and Ms. Hayes do the right thing before it’s too late and they do even more damage to Oregonians and our state.